Hacking 433Mhz support into a cheap Carbon Monoxide detector

Skill level:  Easy

My home automation systems use two mechanisms for communication:  Ethernet (both wired and wireless) and 433MHz OOK radio.

433MHz transmitters are readily available and are cheap but unreliable.  Wifi enabled MCUs such as the ESP8266 are also cheap (coming in at around the same cost as an Arduino clone, a 433MHz transmitter and a bag of bits to connect them together), they are reliable enough but extremely power hungry.  If I can plug a project into the mains then I’ll use an ESP8266 and a mobile phone charger for power, if the project needs to run off batteries then a 433MHz equipped Arduino is the way I’ve gone.

Like most people playing with 433MHz radio I found reliability and range of the radio link to be super flaky.  I’ve finally got a more-or-less reliable set-up:

  • A full wave dipole antenna at the receiver
  • A high quality receiver from RF Solutions in place of the cheap ones which are bundled with transmitters. A decent receiver on eBay
  • A big capacitor on the transmitter.  I saw the frequency and amplitude drifting massively during transmission.  Adding a 470µF cap helps.  Allow time for the cap to charge and the oscillator to stabilise, a few seconds delay seemed to do the trick.
  • Using the RCSwitch library on the transmitter:
    • RCSwitch mySwitch = RCSwitch();
    • mySwitch.setProtocol(2); // Much longer pulse lengths = much better range?
    • mySwitch.setRepeatTransmit(20); // Just brute-force it!

With this setup I can get receive a 24bit number from an Arduino running off 2 AA batteries and a coiled 1/2 wave antenna from about 5 meters indoors through walls.  That’s still poor, but it does the job.  Increasing the voltage to the transmitter would probably help.

Once you have a reliable 433MHz receiver setup then you can also buy off the shelf 433MHz enabled home automation gizmos like this smoke alarm or these door sensors.  They have a set of jumpers inside where you can set an ID, which is essentially the same 24bit number that RCSwitch lets you transmit.  For what it’s worth I also have kite-marked smoke detectors in my house, but from the testing I’ve done with a bit of smoldering paper the cheap imports work just fine.

I couldn’t find a cheap Carbon Monoxide which also has 433MHz support so I thought I’d quickly hack one together out of this Carbon Monoxide detector and an Arduino clone and 433MHz radio:

CO Alarm inside

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

IMG_1238

You can barely notice it!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It’s certainly untidy, but it does the job.  If I had PCB facilities at home I’m fairly sure it could be made to fit inside the alarm, along with some more holes in the case for ventilation.

The premise is simple enough.  The Arduino is powered by the 3v3 regulator on the CO alarm PCB.  The cathode of the red alarm LED is connected to pin 2 of the Arduino as an external interrupt.  When the pin goes low the Arduino wakes up and sends it’s 24bit ID number over the radio which is picked up by the receiver which sends an SMS alert, switches the boiler off, etc.  I’ve connected the radio transmitter to directly to the 3 x AA batteries (4.5 volts) via a transistor which is switched by a pin on the Arduino.  In standy-by mode the additional equipment draws a fraction of a milliamp and so I’m not worried about draining the batteries faster.

As with the smoke alarms, this is not my only source of Carbon Monoxide detection.  I’ve yet to test it’s sensitivity.  This is considered to be a “well, if it works, and it turns the boiler off automatically then it’s certainly worth a go, but I’m not relying on it” project.

HOWTO: Very low power usage on Pro Mini V2 (Arduino clone)

Skill level:  Easy enough if you’ve got a soldering iron.

Introduction

The Pro Mini V2 is an Arduino Pro Mini clone available on eBay for, typically, £1.50.  The version I buy is adjustable between 5v and 3.3v and has an ATmega 328 clocked at 8 MHz.  It’s an ideal board for development of IoT remote sensors and great for playing with and learning about the Arduino development environment.

Here’s a link to the version I buy and know works: 3V Pro Mini 2 Arduino Clone

When you want to put a sensor in a remote location the last thing you want to do is have to run a power cable to it. I’ve experimented with solar with generally poor results so battery operation is the obvious solution.  While Li-ion batteries offer higher energy density the sweet spot still seems to be the good ol’ alkaline battery.  They’re cheap, safe, recyclable and readily available.

For what it’s worth the Ikea alkaline batteries offer good value:  http://www.batteryshowdown.com/results-lo.html (I suggest buying as many packets as you can carry, so that you never ever have to go back there.  Unless you like arguing with your wife of course.)

Power Usage

The ATmega 328 has various power saving functions which involve putting it to sleep when not doing anything.  I use the Rocket Scream Low Power library to take care of putting the processor into a low power state, but I wasn’t seeing anything like the low power savings they detail on their site.

Some quick calculations:  Let’s assume a AA battery provides 2000 mAh.  I measured my Pro Mini V2 as drawing 6.7mA when powered up and doing things and 2.8mA when in sleep mode.  As a conservative estimate, let’s say it’s running for 1 hour in every 24 hour period and asleep the rest of the time.  That averages out to about 3mAh of draw.

For a 2000 mAh battery, that would give about 667 hours of runtime, or 28 days. So a standard Pro Mini V2 could run for about a month on a pair of AA batteries.  Not bad, but I think changing the batteries every month is still going to be a bit of a drag. Besides, Rocket Scream are seeing power usages in the micro-amps range when asleep.  There is clearly work to do.

How to dramatically reduce the power consumption

In this photo you can see I’ve identified some sections which are related to the power usage of the Pro Mini.

arduino_highlightsThe red section is the power LED.  This is always on when power is applied and sucks about 0.2mA when lit. If you don’t need this to be lit all the time then you can easily remove it to save some juice.  I found the easiest way was to use a pair of cutters to snip/crush the middle of the LED and then use a soldering iron to remove the bits left over.

The green section is the on-board regulator.  If you are going to be supplying power to the board via a couple of AA batteries (each battery being 1.5v, so two is 3v) then you don’t need the regulator.  You can cut this off too if you like, but.. keep reading, there’s no need to hack it off.

Saving the best until last, the yellow section is the power-selection jumper to switch between 3.3v and 5v.  It passes the power supplied by the RAW pin through the regulator and on to the board.  The regulator is inherently inefficient.  You might think that you could bypass the on-board regulator by powering the board by apply power to the Vcc pin instead, but it still seems to power the regulator.  By simply unsoldering this jumper you can disable the on-board regulator and save loads of power.  Once removed you will need to apply power to the Vcc pin at ~ 3.3V.  I used some solder-wick to clean up but you could just scrape it off with a soldering iron if you need to.

Here’s one I prepared earlier.

IMG_1029

With the jumper and LED removed. (Red and yellow boxes from previous image)

 

With the LED and solder jumper removed I measured the power usage again.  Running current is now down to 3.8mA, pretty much half of what it was.  But, most impressively the power used when asleep is down to 0.004mA.  4 microamps! Yay!

Some more quick calculations based on the same usage as before:  average power consumption drops to 0.17mA.  That gives us 490 days, 1.3 years run time off a pair of AA batteries.  That should allow for 2.5 minutes “work” an hour.  Waking up, taking some readings and sending them off via a radio should take well under 1 minute, which should allow for more power usage by a radio.

 

 

 

Conclusion

Unless you’re going to run your Arduino off a permanently attached serial connector, then just do this.  Get yourself a couple of AA batteries & a battery holder.  Apply the +ve side of the batteries to Vcc and the -ve to ground.  Stick your multi-meter in between the battery and Vcc pin to measure the lovely low current usage.  You can read the battery power being provided with the Secret Arduino Volt-meter trick.

I’ve got quite a few sensors around the house running with this set-up so I will monitor battery usage over the next few weeks or months and report back.

 

Coming Soon…

A write up of my cheapo IoT sensor network, including smoke detectors, door contact sensors, movement sensors, house-plant watering monitors, room temperature sensors and a weather station.  Plus, build an IoT sensor and buy a sausage roll for less than a fiver.